Oonotus adspersus

Assessor: Riaan Stals

Sensitive in 2010
Yes
Family
Lucanidae
Exploitation extent
Small or insignificant - wild individuals of the species are known to be exploited, collected, traded or utilized in a targeted manner, but utilisation is localised and/or affects only a small proportion of the wild population.
Justification and references

 

1. Taxonomy

Oonotus (Oonotus) adspersus (Boheman, 1857)

FAMILY Lucanidae (stag beetles)

English: Coastal Small Stag Beetle

iSiZulu: iNkubabulongwe

Taxon concept: The species concept employed here is that of Endrödy-Younga (1993).

 

 

2. Prior, existing or proposed conservation status

 

2.1. IUCN Red List of Threatened Species

First evaluation in May 2011. Submitted to IUCN, but unpublished.

Red List Status: Near Threatened: NT B1ab(ii,iii,v).

Rationale:

  • Endemic to the Republic of South Africa. Known from 13 locations, but likely to occur at a few more, since there remain unsampled suitable patches of forest habitat within the known range of the species. 

  • EOO = 19,831 km² (global).

  • Experiencing ongoing loss of habitat to crop cultivation and decline in habitat quality due to invasive alien plants, the presence of cattle, inappropriate fire management and extraction of forest products.

  • Adult specimens are harvested to supply the beetle collector's trade.

◘◘ Of the 13 known localities where this species occurs, nine have to date not been made known through publication in print media or on the internet.

REFERENCE: Stals, Armstrong & Raimondo (2011a).

 

2.2. Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES)

Unlisted.

REFERENCE: CITES Appendices valid from 2017-10-04.

 

2.3. Threatened or Protected Species (ToPS) list, 2007

Listed in category: Protected Species.

 

2.4. Threatened or Protected Species (ToPS) list, revised 2011 (unpublished)

•• Revised lists published for public comment: Notice 389 of 2013, Government Gazette No. 36375, 16 April 2013.

Unlisted. 

 

2.5. National Sensitive Species List, 2010

Listed.

 

2.6. KwaZulu-Natal Environmental, Biodiversity and Protected Areas Management Bill, 2014 (draft)

Listed in Schedule 3 as Protected Animal Species.

 

 

3. Exploitation extent

Specimens of any and all Lucanidae (stag beetles) have for many decades been probably the most sought-after beetles among armchair and safari collectors in affluent communities. A simple Google search will reveal the enormous extent of international trade in stag beetles, both as dead, preserved specimens and as livestock. Four clear trends are, and have always been, discernible in the trade of collectable beetles:

  1. Larger beetle species are more valuable than smaller species and command higher prices; and there is more trade in larger species than in smaller species.
  2. Larger individual specimens within any collectable beetle species are more valuable than smaller specimens and command higher prices; and there is more trade in larger specimens than in smaller specimens.
  3. Rare, scarce and other difficult-to-obtain beetle species are more valuable than commoner species or species that are easier to obtain, and rare and scarce beetle species command higher prices.
  4. There is a synergistic interaction among the above three variables.

 

The species of the stag beetle genus Oonotus are small beetles, leading to them not being highly popular among purchasing or poaching collectors. This situation may however change, for the following reasons, among others:

  1. Wealthy armchair and safari collectors of insects have a general aim to own a "complete" collection, meaning representative specimens of all the species and subspecies within a focal taxonomic group, in this case the family Lucanidae (stag beetles). Some collectors have a worldwide interest, whereas the interest of others may focus on one of more specific geographic areas, e.g. Africa. In pursuit of "complete" collections, they will necessarily also wish to purchase or collect smaller-bodied species, such as those of Oonotus.
  2. Some of the Oonotus species are demonstrably among the rarest of all stag beetles, with Oonotus sericeus outperforming all the others therein that only a single specimen of that species has ever been collected (as far as it has been made known).
  3. For perhaps more than a century and a half already, "gentleman collectors" have been advised of what species are potentially available for them to obtain through catalogues, more often than not published by purveyors of deadstock. This practice reached its pinnacle with the luxurious, beautiful and exceptionally expensive books published since 1999 by Taita Publishers in the Czech Republic.
         The books published by Taita clearly serve both as appetisers for the wealthy beetle collector and as modern shopping catalogues, brilliantly illustrated with large photographs on thick glossy paper, representing the gamut of what an armchair collector would like to buy for his collection in order for it to become "complete". It is telling that the cofounder of Taita Publishers, as well as its most prolific author, was the late Karl 'Charly' Werner, somebody who was an unashamed beetle dealer and who over decades spent large amounts of time in Africa collecting rare beetles [or purportedly rare beetles] to sell at astonishing prices in the northern hemisphere. Werner never made any secret of his occupation and the source of his wealth.
         For the Lucanidae (stag beetles) of the Afrotropics, Taita published in 2004 a truly magnificent book (Bartolozzi & Werner 2004) in which the genus Oonotus was made known to collectors worldwide for the first time, "advertised" with large and magnificent photographs of all four known species. Because of this book, my coleopterist colleagues and I suspect that specimens of Oonotus, despite being small, have now moved into the visor of those that sustain the demand for rare collectable beetles. Previously they were obscure and known only to those that peruse the primary taxonomic literature. I suspect that trade in Oonotus specimens may be much larger than what I could find evidence for (below).

 

Hard evidence for trade in Oonotus species

I have no evidence for trade in any Oonotus specimens besides that below.

 

During January and February 2018 I scoured the internet for instances where any Oonotus specimens were offered for sale, or where a such a transaction had been concluded. I found only a single such instance.

(1) One specimen of Oonotus adspersus (THE SPECIES IN THIS PARTICULAR EVALUATION) offered for sale on the 'eurofauna.com" website by a person apparently based in China.

»»» Click HERE for a permanently archived cache of that webpage.

 

(◘) I did locate another instance which is a smoking gun. Colin R. Owen of Somerset West, South Africa, has been known as a beetle dealer since at least 1985 (documentation in my care). He operates the website beetlesofafrica.com, which is a display of what must be Africa's most sought-after beetles (for an armchair or safari collector). Only a small number of the beetle species displayed on Owen's website are on the site itself offered for sale. Displayed on Owen's website is the species Oonotus interioris (misspelled as "Oonutus interioris"), but this species is not offered for sale on the site itself.

»»» Click HERE for a permanently archived cache of that webpage.

On this webpage the detailed collecting data of the displayed specimen is given. The most intriguing part of this detective story is that a photo of a specimen of this species (but not the same specimen!) with exactly the same collecting data, but with added that the specimen was collected by C.R. Owen, appears on page 21 of the luxurious catalogue by Bartolozzi & Werner (2004). The specimen figured in the book is credited to [now] belong to the collection of Luca Bartolozzi, Florence, Italy.

This is not conclusive evidence of any beetles having been sold, but it is a smoking gun.

 

(◘) Another smoking gun is the photographs of two other, different, specimens of Oonotus interioris that appear on the same page 21 of Bartolozzi & Werner (2004). On that page it is stated that both specimens were collected by a South African citizen suspected to be a beetle dealer, but whose name I shall not divulge here. Both those specimens are credited to having belonged to the collection of Karl Werner, Peiting, Germany (see above). Werner passed away after the publication of this book.

Again this is not conclusive of commercial dealing in any beetles, but it is another smoking gun.

 

◘◘ Of the 13 known localities where this species occurs, nine have to date not been made known through publication in print media or on the internet.

 

 

4. References

Bartolozzi L, Werner K (2004) Illustrated Catalogue of the Lucanidae from Africa and Madagascar. Taita Publishers, Hradec Králové, Czech Republic. 191 pp. Book homepage at publisher.

Endrödy-Younga S (1993) The southern African lucanid genus Oonotus Parry with descriptions of a new subgenus and three new species (Coleoptera: Scarabaeoidea). Annals of the Transvaal Museum 36(5): 31–40. Persistent link.

Stals R, Armstrong AJ, Raimondo D (2011a) Oonotus adspersus. IUCN Red List Assessment. Submitted to IUCN, but unpublished. On file with the South African National Biodiversity Institute (SANBI).

Population vulnerability
Population is not vulnerable: size is > 2500 mature individuals, AND the number of known subpopulations is > 5 AND range > 100km2
Justification and references

The population of Oonotus adspersus is not vulnerable for the following reasons:

  1. The population size is unknown.
  2. The species is known from 13 locations, but likely to occur at a few more, since there remain unsampled suitable patches of forest habitat within the known range of the species. Of the 13 known localities where this species occurs, nine have to date not been made known through publication in print media or on the internet.
  3. EOO = 19,831 km² (global; endemic to the Republic of South Africa).

REFERENCE: Stals R, Armstrong AJ, Raimondo D (2011a) Oonotus adspersus. IUCN Red List Assessment. Submitted to IUCN, but unpublished. On file with the South African National Biodiversity Institute (SANBI).

Targeted demographics
Mature (breeding) individuals are killed, significantly weakened or are permanently removed from the wild, OR immature individuals are targeted and this significantly impacts mature (breeding) individuals.
Justification and references

Adult beetles are collected and killed to be preserved in insect collections.

 

Some proof:

»»» Click HERE for a permanently archived cache of a specimen OF THIS SPECIES offered for sale on a European website.

»»» Click HERE for a permanently archived cache of a webpage that displays a preserved Oonotus specimen.

Regeneration potential
Unknown
Justification and references

No information exists about the regeneration potential of this species.